I hope you are happy Badge, you might not go down alone after this. I guess he's called Martin the mad for a reason with all of this going down
What Burns did/acted upon was a bit in the meta, it seems to me, which is why I wanted a perception roll in the first case to check if it was within reason for her to know what had gone on in the arena. Since I've set the DC to 10+ (1 per 10 ft away)+1 for noise there was a good chance people didn't hear it (like all the commoners not around the death dog haven't heard it).
If they had just yelled it out then yeah it wouldn't be a big deal to hear it, but fighting is going on with a lot of frightened people making noise and also a crowd cheering on the slaughter. I'm not sure if the DC is too hard for 5e as I've not really noticed any suggestions on how to select a DC so I'm just going for what I remember from 3.5 dialed down a bit.
I'm also not going to disallow this behaviour as I find it fun to see what happens in this setting but I hope all involved in this game won't take any pvp personally whether it was planned by me or as a sudden surprise.
For new characters I want everything rerolled, but I'll be kind enough to let you keep the xp
